He says the cry of the poor is not always just that means sometimes slaughtering poor people might be justifiably. The growth of the Western industrialized world was intimately tied to the persecution of indigenous peoples in the New World—and, for that matter, to people in other undeveloped parts of the world, especially Africa, Asia, and South America. Please note the page and paragraph numbers Paraphrase his thesis in your own words. European explorers reported that the Indians were incredibly kind, gentle, and generous. The English preferred the trick the Indians into thinking they had peaceful motives and then massacring the unarmed Indians. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Does his thesis have merit?
Instead of the usual, idealized vision of North American colonization offered in history textbooks, Zinn offers some harsh realities about brutality of the colonization. They used irrigation canals, ceramics, made cloth out of cotton, and weaved baskets before European explorers. Zinn quotes the writer Albert Camus: Africa also impressed the Europeans with their well-built economic structure and the trade within cities. He had intended to sail to Asia; he was lucky that he found North America in the middle of his voyage, since, otherwise, he and his crew would have starved.
But of course, fr excuse ignores the basic greed and acquisitiveness of the European colonists: Otherwise, he and other historians would be implicitly accepting murder and violence. Howard Zinn unequivocally mentioned his thesis regarding first chapter in several places in his book “A people’s history of the United States”. According to Zinn, how is Columbus portrayed in traditional history books?
Home About Story Contact Help. It is too late for that; it would be a useless scholarly exercise in morality. Thus, we must question the assumption that the Europeans were morally justified in conquering the Indians.
Basically the thesis means that we must not accuse, judge, and condemn Columbus absence. Howard ZInn says my point is not that we must, in telling history, accuse, judge, condemn Columbus absentia. In response, Indians massacred English men, women, and children.
Reform Militarism and Conquest Bias and Historiography. Columbus didn’t initially plan to kill off the residents of the ” New World “, he wished to conquer the land and seemed to believe abusing and killing off the residents was the way to go in executing his plan.
Zinn tells this story from the perspective of the Arawak, noting how Columbus, from his first days in the Bahamas, aimed to subjugate the Arawak.
ZINN QUESTIONS chapter 1 – columbus, the Indians and Human Progress – honeyshistorystudyguide
He is saying that why they need to fight for something they can simply have. Nevertheless,we should not accuse or judge Columbus for his actions Rather it was necessary for progress of America to occur pg. They used irrigation canals, ceramics, made cloth out of cotton, and weaved baskets before European explorers.
A People’s History of the U. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class. The Puritans also looked to Psalms 2: Women died from over working, men die from mining, and children from lack of milk.
Columbus kept them as prisoners on this ship and forced them to lead him to places where he can find gold and they usually died from the cold. Or one can omit facts which might lead to unacceptable conclusions. In Haiti, he enslaved entire tribes, ordering them to search for gold or be killed.
Please explain your reasoning behind all responses.
The words of Chief Powhatanwho led his people against the English in the early s, still resonate: Slave owners lived in fear of poor whites because they knew thess slave rebellion would be foe worse if it had the aid of whites. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does.
He states all their accomplishments that they made without the help of the English.
The Indians were, arguably, culturally superior to the Europeans who conquered them over the course of thessi next five hundred years. Zinn argues that Henry Kissinger only wrote from the viewpoint of the leaders of Austria and England. How to cite this essay Choose cite format: They then tried to make the poor whites feel like they were socially above the slaves to avoid this issue.
Howard Zinn Chapter 1 Study Questions
Instead of the usual, idealized vision of North American colonization offered in history textbooks, Zinn offers some harsh realities about brutality of the colonization. They gave him gold and silver. He does not znns the story of mass murder; indeed he describes it with the harshest word one can use: